Steve Carell gives a captivating performance in Foxcatcher. I doubt whether any actor has worn a false nose so well since Robert De Niro's got pummeled into cauliflower in Raging Bull.
That this beak caps off a man who counted ornithology among his interests
is a fringe benefit; that the real John E. du Pont also resembled a
bird of prey has a downright sinister serendipity. Moreover, John was a
scion—with blood as blue as melancholy—and a wrestling coach; and this led him to bring Mark Schultz, a 27-year-old world
champion, into his fold.
The
film begins in 1987—three years after Mark (Channing Tatum) was
awarded his gold medal in Los Angeles. Wherever he is now, it certainly
could use that California sun; he grunts out an inspirational speech for
a gray assemblage of elementary-school kids who look too tired to
yawn. He trains with his brother Dave (Mark Ruffalo), a fellow Olympic
gold medalist who is also a wrestling coach at a university. Between the
wife, kids, job, and receding hairline, one wouldn't guess that, in
real life, Dave was only a year older than Mark. There's the suggestion
that Mark, affectless and laconic, is developmentally disabled—and
that's off-putting because it plays into stereotypes about wrestlers,
and because Mark wrote the book this movie is based on.
To paraphrase John Cage, Birdman is too insecure to know what to say, but it is saying it. Screeching it from Manhattan rooftops. The movie doesn't eat crow; it regurgitates it. And yet, like Whiplash, it's full of infectious energy—false energy to be sure, but enough voltage to power up a smile, and maybe a few seizures. The problem is that it's at Michael Keaton's expense. In affect, the film is the opposite of Wes Andersonia—it's more like a backstage musical that breaks out in fights rather than songs—but, as a work of art, it's made impotent by its irony. It flatters the audience by playing off popular preconceptions of what showbiz people are like; shits on Middle Americans (like a multi-chinned family that wants its picture taken with Keaton's movie-star character); and then shits on artists because having aspirations only means jerking off your ego. Right in the middle of the ensemble is Keaton, playing a washed-up Hollywood actor who's writing, starring in, and directing an adaptation of a Raymond Carver story that's about to premiere on Broadway. He's like Marcello Mastroianni in 8 1/2: everything happens to him. Except, potentially, for a devious act in the beginning and a last-straw gambit at the end, he's devoid of volition.
Twenty years after turning down the fourth installment of a superhero franchise, Riggan Thomson is pressing bleakly past middle age, having sold out, then cashed out; he's gone from being typecast to not being cast, and suffers from the lingering apprehension that he hasn't—in the film's mushy terms—lived up to his potential. What a coincidence that he's played by Keaton! Whether or not the particulars of Riggan's career are true to Keaton's own—and my educated guess is that they're not—they are corroborated by our pop-psych, tabloid know-how of the former Batman's "fall from grace," and this completely shapes the way one perceives Keaton's performance. Batman shadows Birdman just as Birdman shadows Riggan. That his performance is excellent, and that, so far as it goes, Keaton chose to play this role, doesn't contradict the fact that he is being exploited in much the same way that Riggan is accused of exploiting his celebrity to mount his return to relevance.
In Whiplash, the golden light of the Schaffer Conservatory brazens its students; they merge with their instruments between those cigar-box walls. Under the tutelage of Terrence Fletcher (J. K. Simmons), the most demanding instructor at the world's most prestigious music school, these students aren't using tools to make art; they are tools for making art. Greatness doesn't mean interpreting music; it means playing the notes flawlessly. By using this definition, the film means to excuse its substitution of jazz for what we've come to associate, in movies, with sports: Whiplash is a crowd-pleaser, from high brow to low, because it takes the drive to win the championship game and moves the competition inward, into the consciousness of an artist whose form is as refined and esoteric as opera or ballet. Talent equals craft plus spite: a formulation that is as false as it is irresistible.
Damien Chazelle, the writer-director, probably couldn't have sold this notion so resonantly if Miles Teller's Andrew wasn't as convincingly an artist and asshole as Oscar Isaac's Llewyn Davis. A 19-year-old aspiring drummer, whose hero is Buddy Rich, Andrew whams on his instrument till the sticks shred his flesh; he takes five to submerge his hands in ice water, and watch the water turn red, before going back to whacking that elusive mole. When he's recruited into Fletcher's band, he becomes the star pupil—which means he receives the most abuse. A lagging tempo can make a chair go airborne; Fletcher isn't a teacher, he's a rabid drill sergeant who'll strike you, call you a fag, or threaten to fuck you like a pig. He beats perfection out of his students, and if you're a perfectionist like Andrew, he gets inside your head like an axe.
No, I never thought I'd do the blog thing, either, but I've been posting movie reviews on Flixster through Facebook, and I feel like I'm taking that venue a little more seriously than I should. Now I can write about whatever and be as pretentious and long-winded as a I want--and even reach a wider audience while doing so! I'm hoping for a quarter million hits by next Thursday, so tell your friends!
See more reviews at http://blogs.kitschmag.com/movies/